Archive for the Category ◊ Ideas ◊

Author:
• Saturday, October 31st, 2026

Two questions developed as I was working on a standing cabinet of my design.

One: Am I likely to be pleased and happy with the final result?

Two: Have I significantly learned from the process so far? 

Answer to the first question: No. But why? 

The solid walnut was excellent, though the walnut veneer did not quite blend with it as I hoped. The other veneers were quite nice, especially the bubinga.

However, the structural function was better than the actual beauty – the art – that I really wanted. Maybe no one else would really see it my way, or even care, but only my name would be on the tiny nameplate inside. 

As work progressed past the half-way point, I began to fell that I really would not want to see this in the family member owner’s home. I also found that they could spend not a lot of money on a fully functional and attractive manufactured cabinet. 

I wish that early on I had changed some key elements but there was no way to go back. It simply would not turn out at the level that I wanted. It would only be “good.” That is not what I realistically wanted. 

As for the second question: did I learn a lot from this? Yes, very much. I especially advanced my veneering skills though I had more to learn about integrating it. I also succeeded in a clever and difficult large area of dowel joinery. Correcting various errors went well with some new tricks. 

So, I was actually happier after junking the project than I had been in the building stage to which I had progressed. It has been a long time since I last junked a project at this far along. 

I would like to avoid this in the future! Yet, that is what woodworking skill and effort can bring. I actually feel better not having completed it than if I did. High personal standards, I guess. I learned a lot from it in multiple ways! 

This was not a sale. If that was involved, matters would require different moves. I did lose some money on wood and some time in the shop but it is all fine.

I am happily on to the next project! 

Readers, those are my thoughts to share. I guess you have been there too.

Category: Ideas  | Leave a Comment
Author:
• Monday, October 19th, 2026

Is creative woodworking art – true art?

Though there are some exceptions, no, building woodwork is not true art. It is about much more than art. 

Does it involve or use art?

That is a different question. The answer is yes, virtually always! That is what’s important. Thus, woodworking is virtually always, at least partly, art. 

Let’s think about the issue and why it matters at all.

Imagine that someone is painting an outdoor scene being viewed. The land, water, trees and so forth are all there available for the painting. The painter, however, changes natural details, color, angles, even entire sections. It is rarely an effort to simply duplicate the naturally existing scene. All is done to make the painting become just what the painter wants on the canvas. 

The painter’s choices are entirely unrestricted by anything the painting “should be” and any practical function of it, such as an identifying record of the scene which could be done easily and more accurately with a photograph. 

So what makes the painter create and “build” his painting? Art. There is no other designing function. Of course, this includes beauty, joy, excitement, sharing, and more. It is surely “art” and not an other overall function or direct necessity. 

All this makes it, nonetheless, valuable and cherished. 

Now to the woodworker designing and building a cabinet – a beautiful cabinet that is going to be useful. 

If it going to be used, the design cannot be made only for good appearance and other sensory criteria. The doors need to open and close securely, the joinery needs to work and hold, and so forth. Wanting the cabinet to look good is only part of the choosing criteria. It must be workable, durable, etc. 

Yet, at every step of the designing and building, the woodworker certainly can and should make artistic choices! Unlike that painter artist, these choices cannot be independent from, or fully govern, the construction criteria.

Is this woodworker doing pure art? With the exception of, perhaps, a carved or lathed figure or piece, the woodworking is not pure art as was that painter’s. Nor could it be.

And so, fellow woodworkers, we are neither purely constructers or artists. Yet we are and must always employ both skills to make things. Do not neglect or underestimate either task!

Enjoy the designing and building! 

Category: Ideas  | Leave a Comment
Author:
• Wednesday, May 20th, 2026

I enjoyed some instruction classes in the mid-1980s by the late, great Tage Frid at the old Woodcraft store at 313 Montvale Avenue in Woburn, Massachusetts. 

That store then was still the only Woodcraft, having moved north from Boston in 1968. Woodcraft started as a one-room shop in Boston’s North End in 1928 and later expanded. Around 1990, the company started to expand nationally. Much later, the Woburn store moved to its current location, also in Woburn. Woodcraft is now 67 stores nationwide. 

It was at the original Woburn store more than 40 years ago where I bought my Ulmia workbench that I still use. From then, I no longer had to use my own rigs. I had built my first bench in 1971. Before that, the first bench I used was inherited from my grandfather.

https://www.rpwoodwork.com/blog/2022/08/23/the-first-workbench-i-built/

Now back to the main topic! 

Even more fun and instructive was talking with Frid years later when I randomly saw him shopping at the former woodworking store in Cambridge, MA. (It became a Rockler but closed a couple of years ago.)

As I searched the tools around the store, I saw Frid doing much the same as I was doing: managing ideas. Understand, this was the renowned Tage Frid! The man who, probably more than anyone else, brought and taught the skills of woodworking to America. To see him searching at the store much like I was, and then have the privilege and joy of talking with him, really struck me.

Recognizing him still learning and thinking about woodworking, helped me understand that what I too was doing was healthy and creative. Searching, thinking, trying – woodworking. 

Of course, as a woodworker, I am just a small fraction of a Frid. Yet, I hope you happily read here and it benefits you. It is meaningful and, ultimately, joyous.  

Category: Ideas  | Leave a Comment
Author:
• Wednesday, April 29th, 2026

The previous series of posts showed and explained four ways to secure wood at the workbench to facilitate work. And there are at least a dozen more ways. It should be convenient to set up, work on, and take down.  

This key factor has been important since the first time you ever worked on wood, even at an early age. Yet often it is neglected or done poorly.  

So, why is it so important and deserves so much attention?

We woodwork with our hands. With good hand tools or machines, the hands ultimately choose and control what happens to the wood. While they are guided by sight, sound, mind, and time, and supported by the rest of the body, the hands make the final actions. 

What usually happens in early learning of woodworking, the hands cannot do there job because the wood is not properly set in place and stable. I think that is the most common confusion when developing woodworking skills and   retaining them. 

In practical summary, I suggest taking the time and trouble to set up the wood well. I bet your hands will do the job as they lead the tools to success. 

Category: Ideas  | 2 Comments
Author:
• Saturday, March 21st, 2026

Only you know, but here are some of my thoughts. 

You are taking a break from work, family, wood shop, and the duties of life to spend a few minutes enjoying and adding to your woodworking. Let’s go over what is here.

Since 2008 I have published here 264,000 words written originally by me alone. (Not including comments.) That is the length of four non-fiction books! There are over 1400 original photos taken by me. 

It is all real and all directly from my wood shop. The only break in publishing was about two years, which you can read about here:

https://www.rpwoodwork.com/blog/2025/07/03/where-was-i/

The site remains quite popular and well regarded according to the valid online evaluation systems.

I simply want to share my woodworking with you so you can enjoy and add to your work in the shop. 

There are never advertisements here. No business or selling for me or anyone else. I do not make a dime here. And that is just fine. No nonsense. No time wasting. 

There is also periodic philosophic thought for real woodworkers – like you. I have been woodworking for over 60 years, always growing in skill. So yes, I do have something to say!

I also aim to getting you thinking and evaluating your work. I would love to know that you are making things, but even more, I truly hope that you are happy doing it. 

THANK YOU, dear readers! More to come! 

Category: Ideas  | 4 Comments
Author:
• Friday, December 12th, 2025

There are very few! Yet I, and I think the readers themselves, appreciate what does come in. 

By the top trusted, popular, skillful blog-ranking companies documenting online, Heartwood is consistently ranked in the top 10 most popular woodworking blogs in the english/US language. It is between #6 – #9. That rates above some major woodworking magazines and tool dealers.  

It has been in function since 2008. Though there is a two-year entry gap before a half-year ago, it has run at the maximum content level in the past half year. The site now has 259,000 words, not including comments, and 1400 photos. That is like 3 or 4 books. All from one author, yours truly, and one small shop. 

The material is hands-on and mind-on useful, and, I hope, enjoyable for you to read.  There is no business or money at play here. Just the beloved woodworking – and woodworkers! 

And, I greatly appreciate the readership – and comments!

Online videos, as we all see, can quickly, amazingly produce thousands of comments. Some are just a few words, but it is communication and appreciation. Written blogs are, of course, different. Video seems to stimulate reply more than writing does. I get it. 

So, dear readers, I hope that some more of you will sometimes go to the clicker and pop in a comment. (I have to approve any comment. That keeps away the massive spam leaches.) Most importantly, your fellow readers will appreciate your thoughts and observations. Of course, I will too.

So, if you have something to say – and you probably do – maybe to put in another side of thought – whatever – I hope you will give it a go. 

Thank you, dear readers! 

Category: Ideas  | Leave a Comment
Author:
• Monday, October 27th, 2025

I have had these small sayings posted in the shop for a long time. I look at them often for their help.

The one from the late Sam Maloof, above, is on the door of my drafting setup. I really need that advice!

In the photo below, it is from the late James Krenov. It is pinned to the top of the tack board just above the workbench where I mostly attach the design drawings for the current project. It is simple, clear, and certainly should not be forgotten.

Shown below, on the other side of the tack board, is a sentence from The Book of  Wisdom in the Old Testament of the Bible. It is a simple way of lifting the significance of wood. Yes, good old wood!

So, there are some ideas you may wish to use. Of course, you surely have your own sayings or bits of advice that would help you in your shop. If you have not already, I suggest posting some.

I also have a few other postings in my shop which I will share in time. They all help keep my mind and hands going strongly: woodworking!

Category: Ideas  | 2 Comments
Author:
• Saturday, July 26th, 2025

Woodwork that you put yourself into creating can last a long time and have personal meaning. Consider that these are among the reasons it is worth doing.

Look back at the item from over 60 years ago discussed in a recent post: Still here

My 50-year file of Fine Woodworking magazine is still housed in a large bookshelf cabinet that I made not long after the magazine began. The beds made for my kids over 30 years ago, used by them in their young lives, are still in the house long after they moved into their own.

Now lately these two nifty trucks are for the grandkids. They are not high art woodwork but as personal creations they are meaningful.

Consider this when you work in the shop: personal connections, the joy of your work (usually), and how it may even outlast you. We work with our hands and tools because it matters.

Now a few comments on the kids’ trucks. They are about 14″l. x 8″h. x 7″w. with specially 10 species of nice wood. Practical, rugged, and fun – constructed to take plenty of playing action. The one at the top has a lifting back, and the other has a lifting lid of its back.

So, dear readers, get into the shop, go to work, and consider what is really going on – and enjoy!

Category: Ideas  | 4 Comments